To verify BIM quantities, treat the model as evidence, not as a finished measurement. Confirm which model revision you have, check it is complete against the drawings, trace a sample of elements into the export, reconcile key totals against an independent measurement, and record every exception. RICS guidance says the quantity surveyor must still ratify model quantities, because they are not generated to a recognised method of measurement. This guide sets out how to do that in practice, with checks you can apply on your next tender.
TL;DR
- Model quantities are generated to the software vendor's parameters, not to NRM2, so the QS still has to ratify them before they go into a bill of quantities.
- Start with housekeeping: model status, revision, export settings, disciplines included and level of information.
- Reconcile independently: compare gross internal area (GIA) from the 2D drawings with model area totals, and hand-measure a sample of elements.
- Hunt for the usual faults: duplicated or overlapping elements, missing items, wrong levels, wrong units, gross against net figures.
- Keep an exception register, and investigate significant differences rather than averaging them away.
Table of Contents
- Why model quantities need verifying
- Decide how much of the model you can rely on
- A verification workflow, step by step
- The checks at a glance
- The errors that turn up most often
- Checking against NRM2 and the agreed rules of measurement
- Checking BIM output against specifications
- When the model and your measurement disagree
- What can be automated and what stays with you
- Working without a model
- FAQ
- Sources
Why model quantities need verifying
A BIM model looks precise. Every wall, slab and door has a volume, area or count attached, and an export to a spreadsheet takes seconds. The difficulty is that those figures were not produced the way a quantity surveyor measures.
The RICS guidance BIM for cost managers: requirements from the BIM model (1st edition, August 2015) states that dimensional data in a model is generated according to parameters set by the software vendor, which do not conform to any recognised method of measurement. It adds that the QS or cost manager must still ratify the quantities, even where the design team follows excellent modelling practice under the BIM execution plan.
There is also a modelling-consistency problem. A peer-reviewed study by Liu and colleagues in Advanced Engineering Informatics (2022) shows that inconsistent modelling styles can produce different output quantities for the same element. The same study notes that models need enough semantic information, such as concrete grade, for the calculation logic to be determined in a BIM-based take-off.
In short, two models of the same building can give two sets of quantities. Verification is how you find out which figures you can price from.

Decide how much of the model you can rely on
Before checking line by line, decide what role the model is playing. The RICS guidance describes three categories of BIM measurement:
- Automated take-off: model quantities used as generated.
- Derived take-off: model quantities used subject to manual adjustment.
- Manual take-off: model quantities that cannot be used, or do not exist, and are replaced with manual measurement.
Most projects will contain all three. Counts of doors or sanitary fittings may sit in the first category once checked. Wall finishes, where openings and junctions need judgement, often sit in the second. Items that are rarely modelled, such as temporary works or reinforcement detail, usually sit in the third.
Grading each element group in this way, before you start, gives you a plan for the verification effort. It also gives you a clear statement for the file about which parts of the bill rely on model data and which do not.
The same guidance notes that measurement is accelerated in a BIM environment, but that discretionary skills are still needed and that the QS remains responsible for the use of data extracted from the model. The categories are a way of recording where that responsibility sits.
A verification workflow, step by step
The sequence below follows the RICS guidance on checks and balances, with the practical additions that a small QS team can run without special tooling.
1. Record what you were given
Note the model name, revision, status, date, authoring software, export method and the disciplines and phases included. If the model came from a shared environment, keep the issue record with your working papers. Without this, you cannot say later which design your quantities describe.
If the model was not issued for the purpose of measurement, ask for one that was. A model shared for coordination may carry placeholder objects, superseded elements or unfinished areas.
2. Check completeness against the drawings
Open the 2D drawing set at the same revision and compare scope. Do all the floors, cores, external works and elements shown on the drawings exist in the model? Are there items on the drawings, such as details, schedules or notes, that the model does not represent at all?
RICS asks the cost manager to check whether multiple or split models create gaps or overlaps in scope. This matters most where architectural, structural and services models are separate files. A slab can appear in two models, or in neither.
If you need a refresher on how drawings feed measurement, our guide to the role of drawings in quantity measurement covers what each drawing type contributes.
3. Run the area check
The simplest and most useful independent check comes straight from RICS. Measure GIA from the 2D sheets and compare it by hand with the model's area totals for floor finishes, ceilings, slabs and similar. If the model's total floor area is out against your GIA, something is wrong: a missing room, a duplicated floor, a void filled in, or an area measured to a different boundary.
The same guidance asks you to verify that elements join properly at interfaces, for example columns stopping at the underside of slabs. Gaps and overlaps at joins feed straight into over- or under-measurement.
4. Trace a sample into the export
Pick a representative handful of elements across different types and levels. Find each in the model, find it in the export, and confirm it appears once, in the right place, with the right type, unit and quantity. Then measure it yourself from the drawings and compare.
Sampling will not catch everything, but patterns show up quickly. If three of ten sampled elements are assigned to the wrong level, assume the rest of that category needs attention.
5. Use clash and audit reports as evidence
RICS notes that clash reports can identify hard clashes, duplicate objects, design or modelling issues and missing objects, and that they can form part of your checks and balances. It also notes that clash detection tolerances tighten from design to as-built stage, for example from 200mm to 5mm for hard clashes. Ask the BIM coordinator for the latest report and read it for items that affect quantity, not just coordination.
6. Check descriptions and classification
Quantities are only useful if each element is correctly named and classified, because that is what lets it be mapped to a bill item. Check that descriptions carry the specification information a contractor needs to price the work, and that classification codes are used consistently. Where a specification note says one thing and the model object says another, flag it for the design team.
7. Record the result
Keep an exception register: what was found, where, how it was resolved, and who confirmed the answer. This is what turns a private sense check into an auditable one. If a tender query arrives six weeks later, the register is how you answer it.
The checks at a glance
| Check | What you compare | What it catches |
|---|---|---|
| Revision and status | Model issue record against the current drawing set | Measuring a superseded or non-contractual design |
| Scope completeness | Elements on drawings against elements in the model | Missing floors, zones, external works or whole disciplines |
| GIA reconciliation | Hand-measured floor area from 2D sheets against model area totals | Missing, duplicated or mis-bounded areas |
| Interface check | Elements meeting at junctions | Overlaps and gaps between slabs, walls and columns |
| Sample trace | A few elements measured by hand and followed into the export | Wrong level, wrong type, wrong unit, duplicates |
| Clash and audit reports | Reports from the design team | Duplicate and missing objects |
| Description check | Names, classifications and specification notes | Items that cannot be priced or mapped to the bill |
| Exclusions check | Work needed for pricing but not modelled | Omitted items that still carry cost |
The errors that turn up most often
The faults below are well documented in the research literature and are worth looking for by name.
Double counting at overlaps. A dissertation held in the University of Osaka institutional archive (July 2020) notes that overlapping regions between compound elements and other building elements result in excess material quantities. A 2022 journal article comparing measurement rules, published by Universitas Tanjungpura, makes the same point for walls intersecting columns, beams or other walls.
Compound elements. The Osaka dissertation also observes that walls and floors contain multiple layers of different sizes and compositions, and that sub-components such as wall framing are usually absent from a model transferred from the design phase. A single wall object might therefore carry a volume that is not what you would measure, and might omit items you would expect to see.
Gross against net. Check whether areas and volumes in the export are gross or net of openings. A model may report a gross wall area while your bill needs net areas after deductions.
Wrong level or zone. Elements can be assigned to the wrong storey, which spoils any quantity broken down by floor. This is easy to miss in a total and obvious in a sample.
Missing items. Some work is simply not modelled. Think of preliminaries, temporary works, working space and reinforcement detail. These need a manual route into the bill.
Unit slips. Millimetres against metres, cubic against square. Always check the units column of the export before you check anything else.

Checking against NRM2 and the agreed rules of measurement
The model's own arithmetic follows its software. Your bill follows rules. The RICS NRM 2 (2nd edition, October 2021, effective 1 December 2021 and reissued as practice information in October 2022) provides the standard detailed rules for measuring and describing building works in the UK, for preparing bills of quantities and quantified schedules of works.
That gap between the software's logic and the rules is where verification does its most valuable work. A few examples:
- Deduction of voids. The 2022 Tanjungpura article notes that NRM 2 requires voids to be deducted only where the area is 0.5 m² or more for plaster, painting and masonry work, while tile work uses a 1 m² threshold. Models usually deduct every opening, whatever its size, so a model's net area may differ from an NRM2 net area.
- Units. NRM2 assigns the unit of measure for each item. A model may offer volume where the rules call for area, or length where they call for a count.
- Descriptions. Each bill item needs enough detail for every tendering contractor to price the same scope. Model object names rarely achieve this on their own.
Compare the model's logic with the measurement rules the contract uses, and note any systematic difference, such as how openings, finishes and junctions are treated. Apply the correction consistently and write it down. Where model-derived quantities need manual allowances, keep the two visibly separate in your workings so that a reviewer can see which is which.
If you structure the bill from a work breakdown, our piece on structuring a WBS for auditable quantity take-off shows how to keep each line traceable. For a wider view of how each bill line can be tied to its source, see linking each BoQ line to its drawing revision.
Checking BIM output against specifications
Quantities rarely fail on geometry alone. They fail where the model, the drawings and the specification tell different stories: a wall type in the model that no longer matches the specified build-up, or a finish schedule that was revised after the last model issue. Reading a well-written specification alongside the export makes those mismatches visible. This specification writing guide shows how a clear specification is structured, which helps when you are checking that every model item has a matching, priceable description.
When the model and your measurement disagree
A difference is information, not a failure. The usual route is:
- Confirm that you are comparing like with like. Same revision, same scope, same units, same gross or net basis.
- Find the cause before choosing a number. Check for duplicates, overlaps, missing elements and level assignment. A difference of one storey's slab area points somewhere different from a difference spread evenly across the building.
- Take it to the design team where the model is at fault. Anomalies belong with whoever owns the model. Ask for a corrected issue rather than patching the export quietly.
- Decide which figure to price from and say why. Where you replace a model figure with a manual one, that element moves into the manual category and the register records the reason.
- Set a tolerance in advance. Agree with yourself or your team what size of difference triggers a full re-measure of the element group, and apply it consistently across projects.
CCM, a BIM consultancy, says in its 5D BIM guidance for quantity surveyors that significant changes in extracted quantities should be investigated rather than accepted without review. That matches common sense: a large unexplained movement between two issues is a reason to look, not a reason to proceed.
What can be automated and what stays with you
Extraction, counting and totalling are mechanical. A model, or software reading drawings, can do that quickly. What follows is judgement: deciding whether a figure is plausible, whether the model's logic suits the contract's rules, whether an omission is a modelling gap or a design change, and what goes into the bill as a provisional or a prime cost sum.
RICS makes this division explicit. It says discretionary skills remain necessary, and that the QS is responsible for data taken from the model. Whatever tool produces the first draft, the sign-off is yours. This is also why we hold that a draft should always be audited line by line, as we argue in why UK QSs must audit every automated draft. Our guide to automated BoQ generation with human sign-off covers how to keep the human review step in the process.
For teams that want a repeatable process around this, the eight-step audit-ready take-off workflow is a useful template for the register and sign-off stages.
Working without a model
Many SME projects never get a usable model. The drawings arrive as PDFs, and the same verification principles apply: confirm revision, check scope, reconcile areas, sample and record. The difference is that the quantities come from your own measurement, so the independent check becomes a second pass or a second pair of eyes.
QuantiFlow is in development. It is designed to read construction drawings and produce a draft Bill of Quantities for a quantity surveyor to review and sign off. The plans published on our site are Solo at £69 per month and Business at £299 per month, with Enterprise on request.
For a wider look at the options QS firms weigh up, see our overview of quantity take-off software for UK firms.
FAQ
Can I use BIM quantities directly in a bill of quantities?
Only after checking. RICS guidance says model quantities are not generated to a recognised method of measurement, so the QS must still ratify them. Some element groups may pass checks and be used as generated, while others need manual adjustment or replacement.
What is the quickest independent check on a BIM model?
Compare GIA measured from the 2D drawings with the model's area totals for floors, ceilings and slabs. RICS recommends this as a quantity check. A mismatch quickly shows a missing, duplicated or wrongly bounded area.
Does a BIM model follow NRM2?
Not automatically. Models calculate quantities according to the software's own parameters. NRM2 sets its own rules for measurement, units and deduction of voids, so you need to compare the two and adjust where they differ.
How many elements should I sample?
There is no fixed number in the guidance we have cited. Choose a representative spread across element types and levels, and widen the sample if you find faults. Whatever you choose, record it in your exception register.
Sources
- BIM for cost managers: requirements from the BIM model (RICS, 1st edition, August 2015)
- New rules of measurement, NRM 2 (RICS, 2nd edition, October 2021, reissued October 2022)
- Liu et al., Advanced Engineering Informatics (2022)
- University of Osaka dissertation (July 2020)
- Journal article comparing NRM 2 and SMPI measurement rules (2022)
- 5D BIM for Quantity Surveying (CCM)
Recommended
- Construction measurement quality control: the UK SME guide
- Seven BoQ Review Steps for UK QSs, Tied to Standards and Contracts
- UK QSs: Stop NRM2 Measurement Mistakes With Practical QA Steps
- Automated Quantity Takeoff: Why UK QSs Must Audit Every Draft
This article is for general information only and is not professional, legal or commercial advice. Quantity surveying decisions should be taken by a qualified professional with reference to the specific project, drawings and contract in question. Content is produced with AI assistance and reviewed before publication. QuantiFlow Ltd accepts no liability for reliance on it.

